Onboarding: if a team member is added, add them to 5 recent relay groups and resend past messages for context #10

New Issue

Open

opened 2023-11-15 09:39:36 +00:00 by missytake · 1 comment

missytake commented

2023-11-15 09:39:36 +00:00

Owner

Adding new team members to old relay groups only makes sense if they can also see the past context; resending messages would be perfect for that.

The resending should happen for any user who is added to a relay group by the team, no matter if they were also just added to the team itself.

According to https://c.delta.chat/classdc__context__t.html#ad63ba1f955c677ccca143d1d12913be8, the bot can only resend messages sent by itself - this is pretty useless for conversations where there has been at least one outside reply from the team.

But IIRC, adb also lets some group bot resend the last 10 messages.

Adding new team members to old relay groups only makes sense if they can also see the past context; resending messages would be perfect for that. The resending should happen for any user who is added to a relay group by the team, no matter if they were also just added to the team itself. According to https://c.delta.chat/classdc__context__t.html#ad63ba1f955c677ccca143d1d12913be8, the bot can only resend messages sent by itself - this is pretty useless for conversations where there has been at least one outside reply from the team. But IIRC, adb also lets some group bot resend the last 10 messages.

missytake changed title from ~~Onboarding: if a team member is added, add them to 5 recent relay groups and resend certain messages~~ to Onboarding: if a team member is added, add them to 5 recent relay groups and resend past messages for context

2023-11-15 09:41:08 +00:00

missytake commented

2023-11-15 10:24:15 +00:00

Poster

Owner

adb says it's not possible - mostly because even if the bot re-encrypts the messages, which are not from itself, to the new user, it can't sign them in the name of the original sender.

So an alternative would be, if (a) new member(s) is/are added to a relay group:

the bot posts an explanation message to the group
the bot forwards the past 5 messages which were exchanged with the outside for context to the relay group

And if new member(s) is/are added to the team:

the bot posts a message to the team that they are added to the past (up to 3) relay groups, and if their presence is required in more relay groups, they should be added manually.
add the new team member(s) to the recent (up to 3) relay groups

This way, noise is reduced to a minimum.

Problem: even if a user adds multiple group members at once, this creates one member-added message per contact. It would still be nice if the bot would catch this and add them all at once, only forwarding the new messages once; maybe waiting 10 seconds for more "member-added" messages before actually adding them to the relay groups would be nice.

adb says it's not possible - mostly because even if the bot re-encrypts the messages, which are not from itself, to the new user, it can't sign them in the name of the original sender. So an alternative would be, if (a) new member(s) is/are added to a relay group: - the bot posts an explanation message to the group - the bot forwards the past 5 messages which were exchanged with the outside for context to the relay group And if new member(s) is/are added to the team: - the bot posts a message to the team that they are added to the past (up to 3) relay groups, and if their presence is required in more relay groups, they should be added manually. - add the new team member(s) to the recent (up to 3) relay groups This way, noise is reduced to a minimum. Problem: even if a user adds multiple group members at once, this creates one member-added message per contact. It would still be nice if the bot would catch this and add them all at once, only forwarding the new messages once; maybe waiting 10 seconds for more "member-added" messages before actually adding them to the relay groups would be nice.

~~missytake referenced this issue 2023-12-08 10:48:27 +00:00~~

Tests: use nine.testrun.org for online tests instead of requiring DCC_NEW_TMP_EMAIL #12

No Label

No Milestone

No project

No Assignees

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format 'yyyy-mm-dd'.

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: missytake/team-bot#10

There is no content yet.